What Are Tariffs and How Do They Affect You?

Tariff Basics

A tariff is a type of tax that is levied by a country on an imported good at the border. Tariffs have historically been a tool for governments to collect revenues, but they are also a way for governments to try to protect domestic producers.

As a protectionist tool, a tariff increases the prices of imports. As a result, consumers would choose to buy the relatively less expensive domestic goods instead. In today’s global economy, many products bought by consumers have parts from other countries or were assembled overseas. As a result, tariffs can also affect consumers of products that they believe were made in their home country.

Many economists, however, argue that tariffs create market distortions that can actually harm domestic consumers over time. They could also lead to the imposition of tit-for-tat tariffs among countries on their respective exports that could lead to a damaging trade war.

Tariffs and Free Trade in the U.S.

In today’s market-leaning global economy, tariffs have earned something of a bad reputation. And rightfully so: many economists argue that they are bad for the economy and harmful to consumers.

For instance, the Smoot-Hawley Tariff has been blamed for worsening the Great Depression in the 1930s. In an attempt to strengthen the U.S. economy during the Great Depression, Congress passed the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, which increased tariffs on farm products and manufactured goods. In response, other nations, also suffering from economic malaise, raised tariffs on American goods in turn, bringing global trade to a standstill. Because of the tariffs during that era, economists have estimated that overall world trade declined about 66% between 1929 and 1934.

Since then, policymakers on both sides of the aisle have shied away from the use of trade barriers like tariffs and instead towards free-market policies that allow nations to specialize in certain industries and incentivize optimal efficiency. Indeed, the U.S. had not broadly imposed high tariffs on trading partners from the early 1930s.

This more or less lasseiz-faire approach to trade in the U.S. remained after World War II, and up until the election of President Donald Trump. Trump was one of a few presidents to speak openly about trade inequities and the threat of tariffs when he vowed to take a tough line against international trading partners, especially China, to help American blue-collar workers displaced by what he described as unfair trade practices. In addition to tariffs on Chinese imports, the Trump Administration also levied taxes on products made in Canada, Mexico, and the EU, among others. These were subsequently rolled back by the Biden administration.

How a Tariff Works

Tariffs are used to restrict imports by increasing the price of goods and services purchased from another country, making them less attractive to domestic consumers. There are two types of tariffs: A specific tariff is levied as a fixed fee based on the type of item, such as a $1,000 tariff on a car. An ad-valorem tariff is levied based on the item’s value, such as 10% of the value of the vehicle.

Governments may impose tariffs to raise revenue or to protect domestic industries—especially nascent ones—from foreign competition. By making foreign-produced goods more expensive, tariffs can make domestically produced alternatives seem more attractive.

Governments that use tariffs to benefit particular industries often do so to protect companies and jobs. Tariffs can also be used as an extension of foreign policy: Imposing tariffs on a trading partner’s main exports is a way to exert economic leverage.

Tariffs can have unintended side effects. They can make domestic industries less efficient and innovative by reducing competition. They can hurt domestic consumers since a lack of competition tends to push up prices. They can generate tensions by favoring certain industries, or geographic regions, over others.

For example, tariffs designed to help manufacturers in cities may hurt consumers in rural areas who do not benefit from the policy and are likely to pay more for manufactured goods. Finally, an attempt to pressure a rival country by using tariffs can devolve into an unproductive cycle of retaliation, sometimes known as a trade war.

Trump’s Tariffs

The conversation about tariffs grew under President Trump as part of his economic policy, which was known as “America first.” This revolved around American protectionism, which typically means more tariffs.

The first tariffs imposed by the Trump Administration were on solar panels and washing machines. Robert Lighthizer, the former U.S. Trade Representative announced that after consulting with the Trade Policy Committee and the U.S. International Trade Commission, President Trump decided that, “increased foreign imports of washers and solar cells and modules are a substantial cause of serious injury to domestic manufacturers.”

The first 1.2 million imported washing machines would be taxed at 20% and the subsequently imported washers would be taxed at 50% in the following two years. For imported solar panel components, they would now be taxed at 30% with the rate declining over four years.

Soon after the tariffs on washing machines and solar panels were imposed, the Trump administration slapped tariffs on imported aluminum. After that, a 25% tariff on all imported steel was imposed in addition to the 10% tariff on aluminum in many countries.

What is notable here is that many of these countries were the United States’ top trading partners and allies, and they were not happy with these additional tariffs. In response, the EU issued a 10-page list of tariffs on U.S. goods, ranging from Harley-Davidson motorcycles to bourbon.

In a survey of economists conducted by Reuters, the Trump administration’s tariffs were very poorly received. Almost 80% of the 60 economists surveyed believed that the tariffs on steel and aluminum imports would actually harm the U.S. economy, with the rest believing that the tariffs would have little to no effect. All in all, none of the economists surveyed thought that the tariffs would benefit the economy.

So, did the Trump tariffs work in the end? According to economists from various non-partisan and bi-partisan think tanks, the answer is a resounding no. A CNBC study discovered that Trump’s tariffs actually hurt consumers greatly and served as one of the largest tax increases in the U.S. in decades. Researchers have also found that the Trump tariffs lowered the real income of American workers and reduced GDP growth. In 2021, the Biden administration worked to undo many of these harmful trade barriers.

Trump’s Tariffs Between the U.S. and China 

A few weeks after imposing these tariffs, fears of an all-out U.S. trade war seemed to be validated as the Trump administration imposed even more tariffs, this time on China. These tariffs came after the Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) released the results of its Section 301 investigation into China’s unfair trade practices.

The 200-page report called out China’s use of preferential industrial policy to unfairly support Chinese firms, the country’s discrimination against foreign firms, and disregard for intellectual property.

In response to what Trump said were China’s unfair trading practices, the U.S. president imposed sweeping tariffs on $34 billion worth of Chinese goods. The tariffs targeted manufactured tech products from flat-screen televisions, aircraft parts, and medical devices to nuclear reactor parts, and self-propelled machinery.

China promptly retaliated by imposing its own tariffs that targeted American agricultural products like pork, soybeans, and sorghum.

The Chinese tariffs targeted American farmers and big industrial-agriculture operations in the midwest; the same political groups that voted for Donald Trump in 2016 and, in theory, had the most influence on his policies.

The trade war continued after this, with both countries increasing tariffs, with Trump imposing tariffs on $200 billion worth of Chinese imports. The tariffs were also shown to reduce employment and economic output, impacting the overall U.S. economy and people’s livelihoods. The tariffs also did significant damage in regards to relationships with other countries, particularly allies.