Dear Quentin,
My former mother-in-law has a life-insurance policy on my 27-year-old daughter, her oldest granddaughter. Is that valid and legal?
We all live in Georgia and have for years. I divorced my ex-husband 26 years ago. My current husband, of 24 years, took my oldest daughter in and accepted her 100% as his own from the beginning.
My ex-husband is an alcoholic, and has a very controlling and manipulative mother. He is currently on probation and not allowed to drive, after five DUIs. My ex-husband is a momma’s boy. His mother is a dishonest and conniving individual who will beg, borrow, cheat and steal for her “baby boy” or herself, because she feels the world owes her.
When I remarried, I was in a court battle with my ex — or his mom, because she controlled the purse strings — off and on for about four years. My ex was trying to get out of paying child support. I finally agreed to it, as I was tired of the fight. Besides, my current husband said that if the ex didn’t want to take care of his own child, he would.
“‘We still continued to battle over ridiculous things throughout the years.’”
We still continued to battle over ridiculous things throughout the years. Not once did my ex-husband or his parents help with anything financially other than what was required by the court, which was nearly nothing. They didn’t help with anything school-related unless required; they didn’t help with the purchase of the first car, college tuition and fees.
They didn’t even help when my oldest asked to go to alcohol rehab because she needed help. I haven’t communicated with any of them in over 10 years. I despise all of them. Fast-forward to today, when my oldest told me that my former mother-in-law has a life-insurance policy on all her grandkids, plus half a dozen other people.
They have never given or even offered financial help throughout the years for anything for my daughter, so why does she think it’s OK to have a life-insurance policy on my child? How can I cancel this policy? I can assure you she plans on pocketing the money instead of helping to bury my child if — God forbid — my daughter passes away.
She is a monster-in-law! Any information or advice would be greatly appreciated.
Former Daughter-in-Law
You can email The Moneyist with any financial and ethical questions related to coronavirus at [email protected], and follow Quentin Fottrell on Twitter.
Dear Former,
Generally, taking out a life-insurance policy on a grandchild makes sense as a gift for that child, rather than as a payout for the person who took out the policy.
In most states, your former mother-in-law would need permission from your daughter, assuming she was an adult at the time, or from her parent or guardian if she was a minor. Presumably, she sought such permission from your daughter’s father. Forging such a signature would be illegal.
Of course, most grandparents take out policies on their grandchildren to help them build up a nest egg for college — even if a 529 account would be a better alternative — or merely as a way to gift them money at a later date. They may, for instance, sign over the policy to them at the age of 18 or 25.
“As extended caregivers, grandparents are eligible to purchase whole life insurance for their grandchildren,” according to SelectQuote, which helps people shop for insurance policies. “The insurance can be purchased in the child’s name, which means the child becomes the policy owner once they are an adult.”
You outline all of the misdeeds and absences by your former husband and mother-in-law, and it clearly is very emotionally triggering that this policy exists. It appears to bring up all of those bad memories and resentments. I don’t doubt any of the bad behavior or how your daughter’s father failed to show up in her life.
“‘Whether you instigate poor behavior or not, you have a choice: You can let them live their lives, or become hostage to their every move.’”
However, by obsessing over this policy and agonizing about how it can be undone, you may as well be married to both of them. Whether you instigate poor behavior or not, you have a choice: You can let them live their lives, or become hostage to their every move.
If you choose the latter, ask yourself what you get out of choosing this path — because it is a choice. Perhaps this anger is a familiar place for you, and the resentment allows you to feel righteous and wronged, and reminds you that you have done your best to be a good person.
Whatever the reasons, these short-term surges of hurt and anger — however valid — do not serve your long-term happiness. The whole point of getting divorced and starting a new life is to leave these petty preoccupations behind. It will only create a toxic family atmosphere.
Taking out a life-insurance policy on a grandchild, someone who is young and healthy, can have advantages. “Plans for grandchildren seldom require an exam, rates will never increase, and coverage never expires,” according to Choice Mutual insurance agency.
For the record, there are two main types of life insurance: The first is term life, which exists for a period of time and has no cash-out value. The second is whole life — also known as universal life, variable universal life and indexed universal life — which, as the name suggests, lasts for the person’s entire life.
Your former mother-in-law could either wait and, in the unlikely event that your daughter predeceases her, cash in the policy. Alternatively, she could use it as a de facto savings plan, and borrow from the policy or money early. Speculating on what she may or may not do, however, is not healthy.
Whether her motivations are self-serving or altruistic, your former mother-in-law will have a premium to pay for every life-insurance policy she owns. If she does not keep up on the premiums, the policies will expire. That’s her lifelong responsibility, and her choice. Do yourself a favor and leave her to it.
By emailing your questions, you agree to having them published anonymously on MarketWatch. By submitting your story to Dow Jones & Company, the publisher of MarketWatch, you understand and agree that we may use your story, or versions of it, in all media and platforms, including via third parties.
Check out the Moneyist private Facebook group, where we look for answers to life’s thorniest money issues. Readers write in to me with all sorts of dilemmas. Post your questions, tell me what you want to know more about, or weigh in on the latest Moneyist columns.
The Moneyist regrets he cannot reply to questions individually.
More from Quentin Fottrell:
• My married sister is helping herself to our parents’ most treasured possessions. How do I stop her from plundering their home?
• My mom had my grandfather sign a trust leaving millions of dollars to two grandkids, shunning everyone else
• My brother’s soon-to-be ex-wife is embezzling money from their business. How do we find hidden accounts?
• ‘Grandma recently passed away, leaving behind a 7-figure estate. Needless to say, things are getting messy’